About Us

We believe jewelry celebrates the individuality of both the wearer and the giver. That’s why for more than 47 years, we’ve been dedicated to providing the greater Chicago area with an alternative to mall stores and mass merchandise.

We make it our mission to carry imaginative designs, gorgeous gemstones, and jewelry that is hand-inspected and finished to the highest quality—all at a fair price and backed by extraordinary customer service.

Every year, we are invited to three invitation-only tradeshows because of our eclectic tastes, openness to new designs, collaborative nature, and willingness to take risks on up-and-coming artists.

Our commitment to pushing the envelope of fashion and avant-garde design even extends to our choice of diamonds.

Hearts On Fire was the first to set the benchmark for consistency and superiority in cutting diamonds to superlative standards under 100x magnification—10 times greater than the industry’s strictest requirements. We are proud to have carried Hearts On Fire longer than another other jeweler in the Chicago area.

Importantly, all of our diamonds are Kimberly Process-certified to ensure that they are not “conflict diamonds” used to finance violence.

We are committed to working with you to find just the right piece of jewelry, either from one of our featured designers or custom-designed to meet your personal needs. We also put a priority on achieving the perfect fit. Nearly all the rings we sell are made to our customers’ specifications in the proper finger size—ensuring uncompromised quality.